Disaster record
Tropical Storm Hilary (August 2023) — Southern California / Southwest
Two years after the disaster 1 death $900 million
Summary
Hilary made landfall in Baja California as a tropical storm on August 20, 2023, then crossed Southern California as a post-tropical low, bringing historic rainfall, debris flows, and flooding to the desert Southwest — the first tropical-storm watches ever issued for California.
NHC Tropical Cyclone Report (Feb 2024): one direct U.S. fatality (San Bernardino County, California). Two additional direct deaths in Mexico.
NHC/NCEI U.S. damage estimate ~$900 million. AccuWeather and other broader economic-loss estimates ($7–9B) include business interruption and wider scopes excluded from the NCEI headline.
NHC Tropical Cyclone Report (Feb 2024): one direct U.S. fatality (San Bernardino County, California). Unchanged through two-year cutoff.
Revisited NHC Tropical Cyclone Report (Feb 2024) and NOAA NCEI U.S. damage tabulation (~$900 million). No authoritative revision within cutoff; headline unchanged from six-month NCEI anchor.
AccuWeather and other broader economic-loss estimates ($7–9B) remain excluded — wider business-interruption scope, not comparable to NCEI property-damage methodology.
Scientific attribution
Climate-science reporting tied extreme Gulf of California / Southwest rainfall to record warm oceans and a changing storm-climate baseline. Verify against primary attribution materials before treating figures as final.
Aug 20, 2023 · Southern California, desert Southwest, and Nevada — first tropical-storm watches ever issued for California · tropical storm / flash flooding
← All disasters · Findings · Inclusion rules
Democratic framing
About these tallies
“Core Democratic Officials reviewed” shows how many of the 54 Core Democratic Officials have been examined for this disaster. Scoring rules: Methods.
Democratic framing
Summary
Despite historic Southern California rainfall from the first tropical storm to hit the state in 84 years, no core Democratic official issued a documented in-window statement addressing Tropical Storm Hilary. Sen. Alex Padilla’s primary Hilary disaster-aid letter arrived September 19 — outside the five-day window — and his August 29 border-infrastructure supplemental mentions Hilary but is also post-window.
The in-window public record was dominated by non-core executive briefings and state emergency operations. Core Senate Democrats and House leadership did not use the Hilary window for climate attribution or GOP obstruction messaging — a thin-response pattern comparable to Beryl (2024) when the core roster lacked an obvious affected-state climate voice in the immediate window.
Republican framing
Sen. Ted Cruz issued a documented in-window statement — August 21 X posts reacting to purported Los Angeles flooding from Hilary (a fake shark-on-the-405 image, then a stay-safe follow-up). Joke/hoax engagement that still names the storm. No climate attribution. No obstruction.
Padilla/Feinstein’s September 19 disaster-declaration letter is Democratic and outside the window. No other in-window Republican statement was added in this pass.
Statements
- Ted Cruz (U.S. Senator (R-TX)) — Aug 21, 2023
Sources
- Ted Cruz duped by fake image of shark on flooded LA highway — The Guardian
- Hurricane Hilary Advisory Archive — NOAA / National Hurricane Center